Settled In Values

One of my beloved mentors was an eighty-year-old professor.

He had me fill out little worksheets the first few weeks he worked with me—ancient .pdfs that  I had to print out and mark up with a pen.  The point of the exercise was to consider my values.  What were they?  What mattered to me?  What did that mean for my priorities?  What did that mean for my approach?

I heard others mock this approach.  It seemed silly to them, I guess—a little “woo” when what they wanted (and sometimes what I wanted) were answers about hard questions like how to get that promotion or how to deal with a conflict or how to get people to listen for once.  Still, I diligently went through the little worksheets.

“Everything starts with your values,” he told me.  “Everything.”

I found the work enjoyable. I knew my broad values—faith will do that—but it was interesting to work them out in a professional context. What does it mean to act justly, love mercy, and walk humbly in an office?  On a normal Tuesday?  Or when your colleagues are mad about a decision?  I made my little lists and determinations.  I put them away. 

I had reason to think of him many times over the past few weeks.

I’ve had to make some unpopular choices recently.  Unpopular because they were reasoned and ethical and in alignment with my beliefs.  And what I find is that most ethical choices become unpopular quickly when they don’t benefit us in the way they want.  Mercy’s great until we have to extend it to someone everyone hates.  Justice is well and good until my own behavior doesn’t hold up to scrutiny.  Honesty is acceptable until it’s outcome isn’t what I want. Peace is celebrated until it means not taking the aggressive approach others might desire.   Everything is good until it isn’t, and until we become unyielding in that choice because it is simply the right thing to do.

I was talking with my therapist recently about people-pleasing.

She told me that people-pleasers tend to want to feel “safe,” and they think they can accomplish “safe” by keeping everyone around them happy all the time.  ‘People-pleasers live by outcome,” she said.  “They do the things they do so that they can get a good outcome. They will do things they don’t want to do, or don’t agree with, because they want to control that outcome.”

“So,” she continued, “the antidote to people-pleasing is getting practice in not basing your decisions on outcomes.  Practice making decisions based on your values.  That, you can control.  Outcomes aren’t always up to you.”

I thought about my old mentor.  Values, he told me.  Values.  And he was right, all this time.

On the days that are hard—when people disagree with me or criticize me, or get angry at me that I’m doing x when they want me to do y—I ask myself, “Am I acting in alignment with my values?”  And if the answer is yes, that helps me immensely.

Jesus instructed that we ought to build our houses on stone, not on quicksand.  And this is the greatest way of thinking about this truth.  How is it that we save ourselves from waffling, and changing our minds every time someone grimaces?  How do you find courage to walk forward in the face of disapproval, displeasure, or unhappiness?  When you know where you’re acting from, and when what you are acting from is rock solid.

Sometimes I think back to my childhood, and all the times that I wanted to change so that I could be popular.  I begged my mom for scrunchies and Guess shirts and Gwen Stefani albums.  I wanted to watch MTV.  I wanted to do the things that I felt pleased my peers.  I didn’t want to be weird or out of step.

Step by slow step, my mother forced me to practice the opposite.  We weren’t getting Guess shirts just because everyone else had them, and it was okay if people thought I was weird because I didn’t have No Doubt’s latest CD, and if my peers weren’t pleased with me we’d all live.  She developed a muscle in me, somehow in spite of our dual generational urge to people-please.  I learned, growing up, that sometimes it is okay not to be liked.  It is okay to not do the popular thing.  It is okay for people to think you’re kooky.

And what a grace that is.

Doesn’t make the days automatically better, of course.  Sometimes choosing the right thing sort of sucks!  It can isolate you; it can cost you.  But remembering your values insulates you from some of that pain, because you know what you haven’t lost. You know what is right and true.  You know what, or in my case Who, guides you.

And that’s worth any amount of praise or comfort you might sacrifice in the end.

Leave a Reply